| theprof00 said: But it's something similar to an earlier game. It was either wonk or abc who became my obvtown because people were talking about previous games and adding confusion. One player came out and asked everyone to stop because they didn't understand the posts and how they related. Any normal mafia noob would have simply allowed the confusion to keep occuring. That was an obvtown sign. [snip] Also, Linkz being gone is really hampering this game. Normally, like last game, by this point he'll have somewhat cleared half the players. I remember quite well. When I died, he was like, the scum team is most likely stefl and truck. NO OTHER SUSPECTS. But for some reason he hasn't done this this game. If he's scum then god help us, but we really need his contributions right now. |
I think you're confused on the first part. Wonk and ABC were both scum their first games, and I believe it was Wonk that asked everyone not to talk about earlier games.
As for the second part, I apologize for not having as much time this game as last, but I doubt I'd have cleared many players this time around even if I did. Last game I had the benefit of KNOWing my 'partner' was a townie, whereas this time I only have strong reasoning to THINK that is the case. I had also got lucky and tried to track a role that HAD to be town, but no such luck here. Finally, I was able to tarnish myself a bit, yet I did more mud-flinging day one that was revealing later on. This time around I made as big a scene as one can make without actually being lynched, and while my analysis of that scene did turn up at least one scum, there's bound to be less connections there because nobody felt pressured to answer anything with my neck looking to be noosed.
That being said, beyond the strong reasoning to THINK ST is town, I'm still stuck on ABC practically confirming Vette. His vote didn't really match his stated stance on day one; however, the attitude I get from him reminds me of the game where he was vehemently opposed to anonymous replacements. Stefl is as close to confirmed townie(barring a cop claim) as we're likely to get and that's regardless of Heph's alignment.
I do not like a Heph lynch today, because even if he is scum power(Tracker or role cop) then it is possible to marginalize him to a mafia goon. On the other hand, if he really is town power then he forces scum to decide whether to block the likely doc-targeted Stefl and kill Heph, who seems to rank pretty high on quite a few people's suspect lists, or gamble some other action.
I didn't like your lynch because I thought you were lying about being vanilla, but if that's the truth than at the very least you're a better lynch than Vette(Seeing as I believe he's town and wouldn't vote to lynch him anyway) in order to confirm the existence of an RB. I STILL don't think that's a good idea though, and would rather lynch someone else.
That leaves GOW and FF. GOW was my 'if there's 3 scum on my lynch, he's one of them' idea, but otherwise I don't recall anything that stood out as scummy to me. For FF it's the opposite, his distancing from my lynch gave me cause to wonder if he was just being careful scum. I'm still going to reread everything and make a better case there. Or if the reread makes me think townie instead, I'll look into GOW.
