The Witcher 2 on Xbox360?

[vlad321]

daroamer said:

vlad321 said:

daroamer said:

vlad321 said:

Why are you parrying and dodging? If you are doing that much you are obviously donig something wrong. With the proper signs and bombs you don't have to worry about any of that and you can just wade through anything. Also the knives are the absolutely best way to murder any boss since they don't seem able to be parried at all. The only thing that blocks them is the enemy's Quen.

Pausing action in an actoin rpg breaks the action, surprising isn't it. If you had more buttons would you have to pause the action? No? Is this a tacical or an action RPG? It doesn't come down to preference, it comes down to what the game is and what concessions the game makes. My personal preference is that I don't pause even in tactical RPGs, but in those when I need to it does not break the flow of the game in any way. Meanwhile I am FORCED to pause in an action RPG, and that is unaccepable. That wouldn't be a problem on a keyboard, but it's a huge problem on controllers.

Edit: Just to sum it up. Does the game have the option to be played as I wish? On a controller just about all the time, it is no. Meanwhile with the functionality of a keyboard, most of the time, it is yes. Therefore a keyboard is better than a controller. You can also objectively measure just how much more functionality a keyboard has than buttons on a controller by simply counting them.

I hope you find a game that is to your liking.

Might I suggest one of these - http://www.freetypinggame.net/

You get to use every key on the keyboard to win!

Don't worry I have found plenty. Incidentally very few of them could be used with a controller without sacrificing gameplay (incidentally Witcher 2 is one of those who have been hamstrung because of a controller mindset and I still like).

But I am glad that you at least didn't argue that a keyboard has more functionality and therefore superior for action RPGs and just fell back on hilariously bad arguments.

You're trying to debate opinion as if it's fact.  I prefer to use a controller, therefore there is no hamstringing.  No argument I can give will ever convince you since you obviously want more buttons and I couldn't care less.  The game plays great.  So how can my opinion be wrong?  You don't like it, I do.  End of discussion.

I'm not going to sit on my couch and game with a keyboard on my lap or try to make a makeshift table.  Controller works great.  Game is awesome.  I never feel like the controls are holding me back from doing anything.

My only issue is you say the design is shit the UI is shit etc etc.  Everything is shit with you.  I just think you're full of it.  The design is fine, your taste is just different.  The game i getting great reviews and so far most people prefer to play it with the controller.  You're the only person I've seen asking to have a key for every item in his inventory because you like to play in easy mode and pretend you're playing it on "hard".

No it is not an opinion. Let me walk you through it. Are there more keys on a keyboard than on a controller? Does that mean you just have LESS options with a controller, objectively?  Meanwhile what are the objective pros of a controller?

It objectively comes down to the fact that a controller gives you less options and less functionality and does not provide you with anything in return. That is a very basic definition of inferior right there.

P.S. Having a pause in game is extremely scrubbish in an action RPG, but I like your spin there.

Edit: The UI is also objectively shitty. If it take 3 clicks to get to any section of the UI, then there is something wrong with it (or it is designed for an inferior control mechanic, as is the case here). Or the inability to sort the inventory, seriously I had that shit back in the 90s. The UI in general is extremely, painfully consolified (meaning, shoehorned into a controller scheme, not a proper one). THe only thing that makes this a more of a PC game is the difficulty, some of the weak themes, and the ability to have a pretty different playthrough each time. There is almost no pampering for the scrubs.