The Witcher 2 on Xbox360?

[vlad321]

daroamer said:

vlad321 said:

daroamer said:

vlad321 said:

daroamer said:

vlad321 said:

Did you at all read the post in this very thread about the shit mechanics they have to make to shoehorn the game on a controller and that they wouldn't exist if the game treated the keyboard as a keyboard not as some limited controller that doesn't have enough buttons?

Did you read the part where it plays awesome with a controller?  I don't see how the mechanics are shit if it plays beautifully.

It plays beautifully on a controller BECAUSE the mechanics are shit.....

No, it plays beautifully on a controller because that was what it was designed for.   You might have designed it differently, but it doesn't mean it's shit. 

I MUCH prefer playing on a controller to playing on a keyboard so I'm glad they designed it to work that way.  The game is one of the best RPGs I've ever played.

No it definitely means it's shit if the fluidity of the gameplay has to be broken up due to a deficiency, which wouldn't have been had it been made properly for a keyboard.

Right, so every RPG that has ever had you pause to make tatical decisions is shit?  LOL 

I find the game play extremely fluid.  I also don't want a keyboard sitting on my lap while I play on the couch.  The mechanics are awesome.  In my opinion of course.  Obviously your opinion is different.

Just the action ones where the action has to be stopped. Furthermore that is not an opionin, since you can objectively measure how much the game is broken up. Had I specialized in magic instead of swordsman I would probably be bitching a lot more about this game.

The tactical rpgs are a WHOLE different animal where the gameplay is more about your smarts and less about how fast you do things, so a pause isn't even close to being as detrimental. Though to be fair, I never pause in games like Baldur's Gate, Neverwinter nights, and Dragon Age either because I find it annoying as hell.