I'm enjoying it, but there a lot of flaws. For starters I don't think the interrogation system is anywhere close to being as good as has been made out in general. I've had multiple occasions now where I've had a piece of evidence that connects the suspect to the case, so you try and follow the questioning and wait for a chance to pick lie so you can point out this evidence, but the right question never comes up, or worse, it does and you pick lie, and then he goes and pulls a 180 and accuses the suspect based on something else that you can't prove.
That's true with all of them though, as the three options can sometimes go wildly off tangent with what you might expect. It's like you pick doubt so you wouldn't necessarily expect a full blown accusation, but then he starts shouting and ranting about how he thinks the suspect has gone on a wild killing spree or something, when to me you'd be looking at trying to trip the suspect up logically.
I think if you could pick specific questions to ask after picking each initial topic in the notebook (as you would in various RPG or classic adventure games), rather than just a generic 'truth, doubt, lie' option then it would be a hell of a lot better.
I also don't like how you can't go back if you get a question wrong without replaying the case. In actual interrogations you'd be hammering the suspect with repeat questions until he/she cracks, not dismissing something if you didn't get the right answer first time around.
But, in saying all that. It's still pretty damn good. It's just not a massive success like previous Rockstar games.
VGChartz
