Which is better Red Dead Redemption or Grand Theft Auto IV?

[9009pc]

radiantshadow92 said:

TheNoobHolocaust said:

radiantshadow92 said:

thranx said:

radiantshadow92 said:

TeddostheFireKing said:

radiantshadow92 said:

red dead, but the ending still sucked balls

did you unlock the real ending? because I thought it was great, sad, but great

there is only one ending lol...and after missions which i did complete. It sucked

*spoileralert*

Technically yes, but for me I was at least fooled, I thought I had finished the game, but I did not. i didn't know you get to avenge your fathers death. (Play as Marstons son)

 

They could have found a better reason for him to die -_-..he died for nothing

*spoileralert*

As far as I'm concerned that was the best way out, the feds wanted him dead and he wasn't going to get out of there alive, why not go out guns ablazing and die like a true cowboy before they got to use his family as bargaining chips. I was touched, sad, angry and that was proabably one of the best endings this generation, slightly overshadowed by MGS4, but definitely epic.

When an ending makes you feel such a combination of emotions, I'd say thats a success, it did what it was meant to do.

*spoileralert*

There was no reason for him to die. He made a deal with the feds to be left alone if he killed his old gang. That was the deal. If the feds wnated him dead, they could have killed him any moment after he finally killed the last gang member (in the mountians). Not wait a few days and then get him, that makes no sense. It just makes no sence for why they would want him dead exactly at that moment. The made a deal, and even if they still wanted him dead they could have done it days earlier. Not wait like a week and then randomly do it. It was dumb and makes no sence.

here is the thread on how to mark spoilers. if you want to.
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=117278

OT: red dead redemption is much better than gta4 in my opinion.  gta4 was to realistic with character I couldn't relate too.  were as red dead it was a man trying to save his family, which I could emphazise with and although realistic it was set in a different era, which was interesting to me. there was many more reason I liked rdr and many more reason I disliked gta 4. of course I wouldn't say gta 4 was bad though I still enjoyed it enough to play it through twice.