Which game will get a higher meta score? Uncharted 3 or Gears 3?

[Runa216]

Nope!  Not a chance either of these games bomb or are a huge drop off in quality from previous versions.  

I figure that Uncharted 3 will go down to ~94% becuase of high expectations and the complete inability to maintain high scores like that long.  Look at LittleBigPlanet 2, it was agreed by ALL reviewers that it was a huge leap forward for LBP, better in every way,  yet it went from 94.5% down two percent to 92.5%.  I see about the same going here.  I figure the singleplayer will be on par to Uncharted 2, but the multiplayer to be a huge leap forward (seriously, looks amazing), but increased expectations mean it'll be a step down in review scores. 

Gears of War 1 wasn't anything special, just a mediocre game with some good ideas, and it got 93%, whereas the sequel had all those same good ideas, but didn't fumble and instead did a really damn good job and got the same score.  Left 4 Dead 2 was a much better game and yet got the same score.  What I'm trying to say is that I expect Gears of War 3 to be even better than the excellent Gears of War 2, but the difference in scores will benegligible, keeping it in the 93% range. 

Overall they'll both be REALLY damn close and I think Uncharted will come out on top when it comes to reviews, but Gears will do significantly more sales.  Both series are damn good, though, and I think PS3 and 360 users will all have something awesome to look forward to, so in the end we all win.