Nsanity on 30 March 2011
IGN
While sales data for Xbox Live Arcade games is hard to come by, Microsoft does keep a public list of the top 12 all-time best-sellers:
1. Castle Crashers
2. Family Game Night
3. UNO
4. Pinball FX 2
5. Battlefield 1943
6. Trials HD
7. Worms
8. Magic: The Gathering
9. TMNT 1989 Arcade
10. Toy Soldiers
11. Limbo
12. Aegis Wing
I should note that Family Game Night, Pinball FX 2, and Aegis Wing are free downloads. So really, this is a list of the most-downloaded XBLA games.
High-rated XBLA games that don't make the list include:
Pac-Man Championship Edition DX: 10
Shadow Complex: 9.4
Bionic Commando Rearmed: 9.4
Portal Still Alive: 9.2
Plants vs. Zombies: 9.0
Peggle: 9.0
Super Meat Boy: 9.0
