Well I've gotta say that the fact he is a Sony fan really tells you that he's going be have a bias against Nintendo. However I find that he gave the 3DS alot of praise. Sure he didn't like the motion control's he also asked for the effect of things flying off the screen at you.
For all I know maybe stuff doesn't come flying out of the screen. I must admit very few 3D movies do either, some try but it doesn't work. The reason I found it doesn't work is because the whole object needs to be visable in the screen for the illusion to work. Example many times in Resident evil objects would come flying at you but be half on the screen, well the popping out effect doesn't really work when the object is only half on screen. Where as the jaw in My Bloody Valentine 3D which gets tossed at you really feels like its tossed at you, why? Because the object is completely on screen.
I suspect with 3DS it works the same, its an illusion, but with a smaller screen it may be harder to get the same effect as theater.
However neither of this guys reasons are good enough for me. I don't plan on picking up Steel Diver and none of the other motion controlled games. Also I'm sure future games may implement the 3D better with the motion controls. Also this is the first time I've heard of this being an issue so I'm a tad sceptical!
-JC7
"In God We Trust - In Games We Play " - Joel Reimer
