By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Spore should have been the Game of the Forever.  It was instead a mediocre pile of junk.

Empire: Total War finally brought the game to a timeline I'd been wanting it to explore since the original Shogun.  And it now had naval battles!  Unfortunately, the AI was even worse than it was in Medieval II, to the point where the game was absolutely no fun.

I'd drooled over Twilight Princess for years before its release, and even bought a Wii day one primarily for this title.  While it wasn't bad, it certainly felt bloated and derivative, and it is the game that began my declining interest in the Zelda franchise.  Please, make Skyward Sword something that grabs me, Nintendo!