Check out Dead Rising. You can pick it up cheaply and it's insanely fun with massive replay value.
A few others: Blue Dragon, Oblivion (also cheap now), and Mass Effect.
Honestly, unless you're into co-op or online play, I would opt for Mass Effect before Halo. Halo is great and all but if you're into RPGs, Mass Effect is a must.
Or check out my new webcomic: http://selfcentent.com/