By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
radishhead said:

No lynch is still better than lynching someone who you think will be town, surely?

Also, I have no reason to believe that I'm more likely to hurt the town than any other member here- if the Mafia decide to revolve their plan around a perticular player, then that makes sense, but they might choose someone else (since I'm likely to be alerted after last game).

If the chances are that everyone is likely to be a townie, I think that we should keep looking until that situation changes.

However, I agree with you that the situations where someone makes a small mistake and it's inflated greatly is bad for the town, because they always seem to end in a mislynch.

Actually I'm thinking linyches give you more information than a no lynch.  And there is thinking someone will be town by odds and there is thinking it by behavior.  On day one there isn't too much behavior to read but does that always mean a no lynch is best?