Against the grain: Why Super Mario Galaxy 2 would be better on the 360

[Conegamer]

A Bad Clown said:

Conegamer said:

leatherhat said:

It would have better graphics- and with equal gameplay the xbox version would be better. Gameplay> graphics but there's no reason not to try and have both.

This is where I have to step in

The key thing about Galaxy 2 (and the first) for me is that the spin attack was implemented so well. How would it be done with the same satisfying feel on the 360?

Also, how about collecting the star bits? How are you going to point at the screen, collect the star bits without ruining the camera?

Not a bash at you or anyone, just questions. I agree that you should strive for both, but you shouldn't sacrifice gameplay for graphics. Galaxy 2 was a good example, but Epic Mickey or The Last Story would be just as fine to choose...

We all know the fatal 360 controller flaw is that you can't play any point and click games...WITHOUT THE SECOND STICK.

BUT THAT'S NOT MY POINT

It wouldn't feel as intuitive IMO, and the second stick is already used for the camera. So that seems to be a flaw in your logic! Then you need 2 more button for collect and fire, then you see it's much easier to just use the Wiimote...

Anyway, would this REALLY make the game better on 360, with all this messing around?