2011 line up ultimately all about Kinect? - Stephen McGill

[snfr]

Seece said:

snfr said:

1. Cherry picking? What does it matter? You said that and it was nonsense, even if it was just 2-3 posts...

I didn't say all PS3 games were, and what i said doesn't reflect the games quality or what they sold, just that I thought some games were massively overhyped.

2. Not worth posting? So you only want to hear good news and ignore the bad ones? Hell, I'm a Sony fan and even I want to hear bad Sony news from time to time. It's not like the world is full of sunshine every day (I hope you understand what I mean...)

Again I already said, most of the news isn't even that, it's crappy blog postings.

3. Let's wait for the next shipped numbers. I assure you we will have hundreds of "Sony does teh OVERSHIPPPZZZZ!" threads again. Then you'll see what trolling really is...

As long as you can come up with evidence they overship, what's the problem? I admit those shouting it without an ounce of evidence should shut up

4. That's just an assumption. The article doesn't say anything about casual Kinect titles...

Kinect = casual to the core crowd.

 

Don't get wrong here, trolling is bad, and I wish some people would stop with it. But this thread is NOT trolling in any way.

1. Well, you can't really judge that, simply because you haven't played these games. But you already had a discussion about this with CGI as far as I know, so I don't want to start another one again.

2. But the news in this thread isn't, so there's nothing to complain about.

3. What "evidence" is there? The only "evidence" could be that shipped numbers differ too much from the ones we have on VGC, and this could also mean that we're undertracking it. I goes both ways, so this isn't an evidence at all. But you know, we have these stupid threads every single quarter, how many times can Sony overship? (I don't want to defend those who constantly scream for adjustments, btw.).

4. Ummm, yes. That's probably the case. But if you look again you'll see that no one made a comment like "OMG, MS only has casual stuff for 2011!!" Until kowen came in this thread it was peaceful, he turned this thread into a hate thread.

But anyway, we are completely off-topic. We should put an end to this.