Why did FM3 score higher than GT5?

[jesus kung fu magic]

CGI-Quality said:

jesus kung fu magic said:

CGI-Quality said:

jesus kung fu magic said:

CGI-Quality said:

I've explained it the best that I can, which judging responses to my words within the thread, it has gotten across for the most part. In your case, I'm not sure what else needs explaining.

So glad to see this site hasnt changed.....

I think I've been pretty reasonable and thorough. I don't know what else there is to elaborate on, you asked me a question, I answered. The end result obviously has us at a disagreement, which isn't a big deal. If there's some part of the convo not tapped into, share it. I'm always down for good conversation.

Ohh..miscommunication....I thought you were trying to bail out or something...

Anyways.. my only issue is the notion that you believe that GT5 was rated "unfairly" . All I really ask is for you to prove that notion in my previous post

It's not a prove wrong/right scenario, it's just my take. Having spent extensive time with the game, and then re-reading some of the reviews, it seems that much of what the game had to offer wasn't discussed in some of them, such as gift sending. In just about every review, it's compared with Forza 3, which is reasonable and expected, but what isn't reasonable is when the review seems to lack a complete analysis of the end product.

Another problem I had was the basis of judging the game on hype, and again, not strictly on the sum of it's parts. I'm not saying that there weren't any letdowns within the game (I was letdown by some of the visual inconsistencies and loading screens for example), but when I look at the entire package, the scores don't bother me as much as some of the words chosen.

I can now see your point.....but we differ on what we define as unfair.

My point on all this is that you flip the release dates you flip the metas although not to the same value.....GT hype hurt in its meta(which I can also see as unfair, unnecessary nitpicking etc.) but it didnt hurt its meta nearly to the degree that FM3 did by raising the bar first.

Im really just using this as a means to procrastinate from studying for my engineering exam ....glad this didnt end up as what usually happens when we have a discussion