I don't think Alan Wake bombed, just undersold below expectations. A million might sitll be enough for MS to break even considering the so called low budget studio. You can also grab a new copy for $20 in the US, so you'll see more sales in the long run.
Anyways biggest two bombs for me were:
No More Heroes 2 - They treat the original owners with awesome sauce and not even half of the people buy the sequel. Shame on the Wii audience once again.
Blur - I'm not gonna beat the dead horse. We all know It's a mega flop, and I love the damn game to.
It's just that simple.







