lols severance I usually agree with you. This time I only agree with some. But I'll state. As it is the op. These are only out of yours.
Critics and Gamers
SMG (And SMBW I'd add for me or any mario game since mario 64) a 8
Resistance a 4 I hate this game
Call of Duty Series ehh 7 A solid FPS
Uncharted... (for me there is nothing really wrong in this game, just nothing really spectacular well nevermind the train mission is pretty spectacular in UC2... but I'd still give it 85 below the average)
By Critics As these are ones that aren't as adored by fans I think
Fallout 3 (not vegas I love vegas) 80 and a 85 (90 when they fix bugs) respectively
GTAIV (Not fans because fans pan the hell out of it when it is still a pretty good game) 80
gears 1 and 2 are pretty much my favorite 3rd person shooter (as the shooting mechanics are better than Mass Effect imo (though I like ME more and it's online is awesome becuase of the smaller rooms/parties)... and would give them an 85 which I'm not sure there meta.
FFXIII... was probably my 5th favorite FF... and it got a meta 81-83 by critics and users so it really wasn't rated that highly. I'd give it higher than that. for me I wouldn't give it below that for the art direction/music/battlesystem alone. It had a flawed story with a world with interesting material that needed to be put together better... not the first final fantasy to have that problem imo. So :P I'd give it a 90
Red Dead: I don't like westerns so why would I play this game.
And Assasins Creed. I might play this game
