Wii boxing vs Kinect boxing. Which do you prefer?

[MaxwellGT2000]

Cross-X said:

MaxwellGT2000 said:

Cross-X said:

Antabus said:

Wii sports boxing does not track your punches correctly and kinect does that. Throw a hook to the liver in WB and your mii propably throws a straight punch... Neither of them care about your stance so it is pretty much who swings his/her hands faster.

Both are pretty bad but Kinect boxing is the slightly better one. I'll just wish someone would make a good boxing game for kinect.

 

Actually those games should not be called boxing, maybe kids backyard fistfighting would be more accurate name.

So true. Wii Boxing is very lame.

Everything else in Wii Sports is great but Boxing. It's just about who can wiggle their wiimotes the fastest.

 

lol? Did you ever make it to pro rating?  Just curious as you can't do that... 

lol No I didn't bother Pro rating because I felt that it wasn't fun at all. When playing with another friend in Wii Boxing, it really doest become who can wiggle the fastest... But then again we were just muckin about and found that that was the only motion required to win, aside from the occasional blocking.

On the other hand... Loved Baseball and Bowling and reached their Pro Levels easily.

Uh Wii boxing is mostly about dodging cause dodging is the way you land power hits, which is how you end up KOing people... 

Sounds to me some people invested time in one game but not the other though the learning curve for boxing on Wii is much higher cause you kinda have to learn what the controller wants you to do, but if you know how to play either one they're similar except in Kinect sports boxing you lack dodging instead you block punches to build up the gauge to do powerful punches, otherwise they're both about getting around your opponents guard with head or body shots.