Community Rankings are unreliable as a measure of quality. Case in point, the general community as a whole has collectively decided that the original Final Fantasy was the best RPG on the NES even though it had numerous bugs and other issues that stopped it from being considered above average.
This is very true, and is why I don't want this to turn into some sort of competition. I'm very much against that.
Still, I think it would be interesting to post some stats about certain games after January 1st rolls by.