I don't get labels really.
Well it probably is an RPG or a game with rpg elements (which imo makes it an rpg :P)... I haven't played red dead. But San Andreas had RPG elements as does Peace Walker. Both games not generally considered RPG.
Another example in a different way is Deus Ex a FPS with RPG elements (And really unique elements at that) But it's generally called atleast on VGC an RPG even though it is a FPS.
Is there an exact definition that's generally accepted? Or is it just what people use to label certain things.







