By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
alekth said:

Hm, bear/born turns out to be a tricky one, maybe just in British English (not certain whether borne is a form used in American English).

The Cambridge dictionary lists (be) born as a separate verb. Maybe it's to avoid two past participle forms? e.g.
She was born into a rich family. vs She had borne him two children.
Or maybe it's the point of view.

Ended up googling for I was borne with the born meaning (rather than carried etc), and even found the two forms in the same sentence, with the same basic meaning. It's a translation of some old Hindu text, so it's probably also made to sound archaic even if it's a recent translation.

She was the daughter of a hermit, and was born into the world in this position in consequence of a curse; and I was borne by her to this excellent Brahman...

Maybe borne in this case accentuates on her bearing the child? On that line, not too sure whether borne would be usable for things that aren't actual procreation. An idea was borne, a new legend was borne ... those don't look good to me, but maybe they'd have been fine in some more archaic text.

 

As for deponent verbs... I actually had to look up what it means, and pretty much everywhere it came down to Latin or Greek and how to translate them into English, which probably means English doesn't have them.
The definition wikipedia gives is: In linguistics, a deponent verb is a verb that is active in meaning but takes its form from a different voice, most commonly the middle or passive. A deponent verb doesn't have active forms; it can be said to have deposited them (into oblivion).

bear-bore-born doesn't fit that, it has active forms; if be born is to be viewed as a verb on its own it doesn't fit the description either since it's not active in meaning.

Borne isn't the corresponding active voice of "to be born." It's a different verb altogether.

Born's archaic active form was "bear" or whatever Kantor said, but this is irrelevant in modern English.

"To be born" is active in English. A verb can only be passive if it has a related ablative of agent. "I am called by by father." "The ball was hit by the batter." I was born by my mother is grammatically incorrect. It is active in meaning as it is impossible for it to be passive.



Kimi wa ne tashika ni ano toki watashi no soba ni ita

Itsudatte itsudatte itsudatte

Sugu yoko de waratteita

Nakushitemo torimodosu kimi wo

I will never leave you