By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
flagship said:
Uncharted would never make GOTY simply because no one bought it. I don't think there's a US site out there with the balls to give a game with sales numbers that poor GOTY.

CoD4 would be a smart choice, it's multiplat so both the 360 and PS3 fanboys can be happy.

 Kotaku gave it not quite game of year overall, but them and IGN have given it best PS3 game of the year, which it it. As I have R & C, UDF and CoD4, I can say that Uncharted wins. CoD may have a lot more time to give, but Uncharted's 10 hours are the best that you will have on PlayStation, and Uncharted does beat CoD on graphics