| Doobie_wop said: Wow, people aren't getting it. I'm not saying that the PS3 has to be held to higher standards than the 360. I think that reviewers are perfectly justified in having a favoured console. I also think it should go both ways, which it currently doesn't. Red Dead, Dead Rising and Mafia 2 should be listed as the best multi plat experience, I'm just saying that games like Darksiders and Castlevania should be given the same treatment. Bayonetta, The Orange Box, Mafia 2 and Red Dead should all have their scores lowered on the PS3 versions, because people should know that those versions are inferior. The same should be said for the upcoming 360 ports. |
There is only a difference in score when the lower level graphics affect the game. Read Dead Redemption is the same experience on both platforms, hence they score the same. Bayonetta was so bad on the PS3 that the experience was affected, and so they scored differently.
Graphics are not important enough in a game, so that every little difference between to platforms and how the game plays on these should affect the score of the different versions.
