I'm inclined to agree actually. Uncharted 1 to this day still looks amazing not just the way it looks but also animation wise, lip synching and in some ways it looks better than Uncharted 2 imo. Like the texture work in Uncharted 1 seems to have sharper and more refined textures while Uncharted 2 in comparison has more muted and blurrier textures. But then again Uncharted 1 has screen tear.
I don't maybe I've got rose tinted glasses on, I'm going to have to check tonight. And I'm not just talking vs 360, it's better looking than all other games on PS3 bar maybe Uncharted 2 or God of War III. And perhaps Killzone 2.
But what a graphic whore of a thread lol.