People are still talking about the first Uncharted? Personally I think Tomb Raider Underworld looks better, on either 360 or PS3. And the game itself is nothing special, it's a bad Tomb Raider clone with too much shooting, not enough puzzles and exploration and a pretty weak cover system that feels loose and unresponsive.
I know people like to compare it with Gears, but it's not even in the same league. Gears has an excellent cover system, and it is actually a good shooter. The shooting in Uncharted feels like something out of Kane & Lynch, it just doesn't feel good or right.