A few things stand out that don't make sense:
Metroid's condemnation of having a similar view point as previous Metroid Primes.... wait.... there's more views than first person shooting? I'm confused on why that is bad. I'd hope in the future that if you were to give us ratings on, say Halo, Unreal, etc, that you be sure and rate them just as fairly and state how it's been done before.
I disagree with Mario's graphics. I've played it, and it looks very very cool on the eyes, very bright, lots of colors that don't annoy (me), sharp, almost no hint of polygons, it's a completely different appearance than any other game... (we've already discussed the Mario Sunshine to Mario Galaxy comparison in another thread. Needless to say it was locked due to the overwhelming opinion that Galaxy > Sunshine, just from simple comparisons... I don't think you'll win that fight)
Sound: I haven't liked 80% of Metroid's music as of late. The snow level seems to be the only music worth finding... so I agree with your criticism there.
Numbers: Checker Players > Halo Players
Checkers Age and replayability > Halo Age and replayability
Therefore, Checkers > Halo
So, Checkers is a better game than Halo.
