zombier on 25 December 2007
@Zucas Mass effect was great as well and should be in the running, but i dont think you can give a game that has some annoying technical issues GOTY. As for COD4 i beat it in like 5 hours. The story is typical, and the online doesnt match what team fortress 2's online is to me. But yea i stick to SMG getting it with bioshock in a close second
