Portrayal of Athesits and Theists in Movies/TV?

[Porcupine_I]

richardhutnik said:

Porcupine_I said:

Kasz216 said:

Are atheists actually underrepresented?

I mean, how would you know?

How many shows ACTUALLY deal with religion.

To have an atheist in a show you would need.

A) A show about religion or that deals with religion a lot.

B) A show who also needs a counterpoint to that.  Aka not a show SOLEY about religion.

I think you'll generally find on the shows where they talk about religion but it isn't the main theme, there are plenty of Atheists.

I just got done watching Babylon 5 again through netflix.  There are a number of atheists on that show.

Or heck, Look at Star Trek.  Every single person on Star Trek I think is an atheist.  Outside of Worf anyway and maybe Riker.  The thing is, nobody knows that... because atheism is kinda useless as a storytelling device.

I mean, if Chandler from friends was an atheist.  Or George Costanza or the fat guy from king of queens... how would you know?   And why would you care?

There is nothing you can do with an "hey i'm an atheist" angle that would work in a comedy or super drama.  Basically you'd need to have it in a dramadey... and even then it's likely to be a plot point that lasts all of 1 episode because there isn't anything you can do with it.

Unlike say, religions where you can have a crisis of faith or there are things you can go to.

The only thing atheism is really "functional" for from a writing perspective is to show a pessimism to a greater force pulling you out of trouble.  Like during  a big war.

So is the "Lord of the Rings" universe, i am still fascinated how Tolkien was able to create a Fantasy universe without Religion, Priests or Gods.

The Lord of the Rings storny is sited by some Christians as one that tells a Christian message.  You have magic, and Sauron.  You have good battling evil.  God is remote in it.

the way you put it sounds like the message is: "even without a god there can be good and evil"

anyway, it is not new, that any text can be interpreted in different ways. but that doesn't change the fact, that there is no kind of organized religion in the Lord of the rings universe.