Munkeh111 on 29 June 2010
I think they are both great games, and while I haven't actually played Alan Wake (the Special Edition is sitting about 1m from me, I just need to finish Crackdown first), I know Red Dead Redemption is incredible and it is certainly longer.
So, if you can only afford one game, go with Red Dead and as others have said, that DLC is worth waiting for with Alan Wake
