Gamespot best of E3 Awards: Kirby's haters gonna hate

[aragod]

selnor said:

zarx said:

OMG the best 360 game is a multiplat which has added content on the PS3 they just out and said that KZ3 is better than Dead Space 2, and both are better than Reach, Fable III, Gears of war 3 etc etc

If Gamepsot rate Dead Space 2 on 360 lower than Fable 3, Gears 3, Halo Reah etc etc. Then Gamespot are away with the fairies. 

There is a reason why these lists are often broken.

Gamespot's game of the year 2009 was Demon's Souls even though it had only 9 rating and there were several games with 9.5 that year.

Gears 3 might get 9.5 for a super polished experience, that have been here 2 times before, without any dramatic change or different gameplay mechanics. Than they might rate Dead Space lower, but still say it's better overall experience despite some of it's flaws.

Also they are judging those games on what was shown at E3, so what score they'll give them later has nothing to do with this, which should be clear to everyone.