It's at 95% charge? That's kind of odd....
On my macbook, and I'm assuming all macbooks, the charger won't actually charge your battery up to 100% as long as it's 95% or higher. But as long as you have it plugged in, the charge will never go down. That means it could stay at 96% charge forever, unless you unplug it and it goes down to 94%. At 94% and below the charger will start charging the battery all the way up to 100%.
Have you checked to see if this is the case for your laptop? Biiiiiiig face palm coming up if it turns out to be true. ^_^








