Well, I still like the site and it's still my homepage. However, it's has become a tad too busy...lol, if that makes sense. So I have to rate it a 3/5. Hopefully as I use it more I will start to love it as I once did :).
On a positive note, I really like being able to simply rate the games in my collection. Also, they show more weekly numbers for the games, especially the newer ones :).