Look I dunno but I can tell you this most movies that win oscars are absolute BORES for me. They might be good technically but apart from A beautiful mind, Titanic, Lord of the rings movies no oscar movie has really given me entertainment.
Anyway I'm not very good at analysing writing & stuff. But Heavy Rain had a good story, it was gripping & had great plot twists. No the game wasn't perfect, no it wasn't art, but it was very good
All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey