Anyone else a bit offended at claims Heavy Rain's writing is Oscar Worthy?

[forevercloud3000]

I think the writing technically would be....if the Animation and voice acting was only on par consistantly throughout the game. In many instances both drop the ball. I think its the fact that the game really does succeed at gripping one's emotions and immersing the player that makes it oscar worthy. Honestly "Swing Vote" is an Oscar worthy film much more so than "The Avatar" because it really tugged at my tear ducts. Avatar had everything on paper right to be great, but simply wasn't to me. Thats how I come to see Swing Vote as Art. I feel it's the same with a game like Heavy Rain to me.