Top Ten Mario games of all-time!

[Opa-Opa]

hsrob said:

Opa-Opa said:
anyone who lists Super Mario Galaxy as number one really needs discover Mario's roots.

So you think if someone had extensively played all Mario Bros games from the beginning up until now, they couldn't possibly like Galaxy the most?

OT: I actually think that is a really good list.  I may not agree with all positions but I don't think any of the games were terribly out of place or that there were any glaring omissions.

If it's your favorite game, it's your favorite game.  Opinions are subjective, and I'm certainly not here to proselytize anyone into another way of thinking.

 

BUT, I would surmise that if you polled those who did list SMG as numero uno, they would in fact have the fondest memories from the "3-D Mario" era.

 

Emphatically, it's hard for me to believe there has been a dramatic shift in formula since Super Mario 64.