| radiantshadow92 said: first of all, that is a ridiculous scale. They should have gone with the 5 star scale. In the 10 scale, good games range in the 7-10. Second off, if the scale is like this, then why did it get the same score as WKC....It makes no sense. |
You're basing your entire argument off of the fact that you don't think FFXIII is equal to WKC. This may be true to you, but perhaps FFXIII really jarred with a reviewer while another (or the same - I'm not sure if they were written by the same person) reviewer found WKC to be, while flawed, quite charming. While the general consensus may be that one is better than the other it does not mean that every magazine has to agree with that consensus.
I really enjoy that Edge seems to have no concern with following the metacritic score on every game, it seems to me that some other reviewers do.
