Mafia Round 15B - Game Thread

[theRepublic]

Words Of Wisdom said:

Thanks for the game everyone!

Any feedback you can give on the following would be great:

• Zombies as town and humans as mafia spin on the Zombie theme (Did you like that?  Would you have prefered the other way?)
• Roles (Did you like them? Were they fun?  Did you like the flavor?)
• Balance (Looking at the roles and the outcomes, did you feel like your team had a chance to win?)
• Would you like to do a similar game in the future?  Or would you have prefered to be in the vanilla round instead?
• Did you like the new vote count system?  Or do you prefer the table system?

- Either way would have been good I think.  This way actually made more sense.  How the heck does a zombie hide the fact that they are rotting?

- The roles were great.

- You said this game was unbalanced, but it looks to me like you did a great job of it.

- I like both.  There is a certain 'purity' to a vanilla game, but crazy themed games can be a lot of fun too.

- One thing I don't like about the new system, is that it gave Trangentspree a way to prove his claim.  Perhaps in the future, non-voting or double-voting roles should still be listed in the vote count as single-voters.  Then only when a person gets to L-0 in the non-voting role case, should the town realize what happened since no lynch occurs.  Same for when a person gets to L-1 for the double-voting role case, and then a lynch happens.

Other than that, I think the new system works just fine.