this list bugs the crap out of me. How is Halo 2, a game available only on Vista, which hasn't sold well, getting more player hours than counterstrike? It boggles the mind.
Also, there is nothing contradictory about PC gamers saying Halo is crap. You said it yourself, the Halo gamers are casual pc games. Casual players have not played as many PC FPS games. They dont usually have another game to compare it too. If they're going to get something, most likely they'll get the game most advertised. If you haven't played many FPS games Halo must seem like the shit. It is the PC gamers who have played many different kinds of PC FPS games that think Halo is crap.







