Sega: Madworld on Wii was a “mismatch”

[Mr Khan]

theprof00 said:
this is ridiculous. The same Nintendo fans constantly speak up saying that sales of games are better when the game does one thing really well or is highly innovative, but here they are saying that the game just plain sucked.
That is a mismatch by the very definition of every one of you.

All I constantly hear is that the games that do badly on the wii are simply bad games. The problem is, no comparisons can ever be made because the same people refuse to acknowledge it. Like Lord above said "And claiming Bayonetta is to indicate sales of Madworld is like comparing an ice cream recipe with a pizza recipe just because the same chef made them."

The only comparison that could then be accepted would be one in which the same game came out on both an HD system AND the wii. Of course, then the argument would be that one game had more options or whatever than the other, or that the gameplay is different.

I guess the only conclusion we can make now is that Nintendo fans should refrain from this "market mismatch"-type of argument because they are arguing an unprovable point from an unaccepting standpoint. Seriously, there is no possible way to show how the mismatch syncs up fairly using one or several titles.

Exactly. The fanbase has collectively disproven all arguments, so only the truth can remain

 

:P