Mafia Round 15B - Game Thread

[Final-Fan]

trangentspree said:

nordlead said:
I clarified why I voted. If a human says "I'm human" there is no reason to wait. If a zombie says "I'm human" then I have no problem punishing poor play. Besides the fact that there really wasn't much to discuss there at all.

Also, the day doesn't end until a majority is reached, WoW decides to end the day due to it moving nowhere or some deadline is reached with no conclusion. I've never seen a day ninjastriked dead just because everyone voted and no conclusion has been made yet. (unless there has been a change to how things work on this forum in the last game) 

Well it was a little more complicated than that for starters. And I remember the reasons you gave for voting him. This is all well and good, but I've already said I didn't like how abrupt you were about it seeing as the town had clearly started to turn on Mario and wanted explanations from him, and how you seemed to want to get the day over with as quickly as possible.

@ And like I said, had I voted 'no lynch' there would have been a majority.

I would appreciate if someone else would chime in and say whether WoW would have gone with the majority vote even if it was below the L-5 requirement? I'm a little confused about this now since Nordlead's post.

@ It was stated earlier that you are factually incorrect on this:  that the No Lynch vote would have been still one shy of majority.  This meshes with my recollections, so evidence plz. 

As for whether WoW would end the day with the PLURALITY vote, probably not unless it was abundantly clear that the town was unable to reach a majority decision.  Which was far from being the case on that Day 1. 

On mods ending days in general without a majority vote:  it's kind of a judgment call, but few mods would absolutely refuse AFAIK.  Most, I think, would rather go with the plurality vote rather than forcing a No Lynch even though there's a plurality for one guy, and most would also agree that at SOME point the day just needs to end.