Mafia Round 15A - Game Thread - Vanilla Round

[theRepublic]

insomniac17 said:

theRepublic said:

Vanilla games can be played with only mafia and townies.  Or with a cop, or a doctor, or both.  Take a look at the C9 setup here.

Zexen's statement doesn't necessarily imply that each of those roles exist in this game (although like you, I think they do).  It means that no other roles exist.

I was just applying Vetteman's logic about the doctor to the cop.

Yes they can. However, I do think that the roles are in this game, as every other vanilla game we've had on this site has included them.

I wanted to point that out simply because you two mentioned that there is no reason to assume there is a doctor or cop. I think that there is reason to assume there is, as that is how every other vanilla game on here has been played.

Either way, I don't like Vetteman's plan myself as it is a bit risky for the town.

As I said, I also think both those roles exist in this game.  I was just pointing out the inconsistency of Vetteman's logic.  He assumes there is a cop, but at the same time is worried there is no doctor.

I think a Day Two no lynch is a bad idea.  I also think the cop keeping guilty investigations to himself is a bad idea.  All this is starting to add up to look anti-town.

FoS: Vetteman