Which PS3 RPG will sell 1 million first Demons Souls or Valkyria Chronicles

[jarrod]

Carl2291 said:

jarrod said:

No, they said some of the figures were inaccurate or approximations, before launching into the usual sort of dismissive tirade that Riley's known for.  I'm surprised certain segments around here would lend David Riley so much credence, given what he's also said about VGC being wildly inaccurate as well.

The Valkyria figures were also leaked beforehand though.  

NPD clearly state that the figures leaked were wrong...

No, they said some were wrong or approximated.  And they never specified Valkyria, who's lower NPD totals were also leaked months beforehand.

Of course if you're taking NPD's view on what's "accurate", you'd have to entirely discount the VGC figures as well.  Again, I'm asking you to consider the source here, read up on David Riley and exactly what he's said before...