Quick look at exclusive games listed on metacritic.
Edge PS3 scores:
LBP 10/10- 96 meta 4 above average.
Demon's Souls 9/10 89 meta 1 above average.
GOW III- 8/10 94 meta 14 below average.
Heavy Rain 7/10- meta 88 17 below average.
Uncharted 2 9/10 meta 96 6 below average.
Uncharted: Drakes Fortune 8/10 meta 88 8 below average.
Metal Gear Solid 4 8/10 meta 94 14 below average.
Killzone 2 7/10 meta 91 21 below average.
Resistance 2 6/10 meta 87 27 below average.
Resistance: FOM 7/10 meta 86 16 below average.
R&C: TOD 8/10 meta 89 9 below average.
R&C: ACIT 7/10 meta 87 17 below average.
Infamous: 7/10 meta 85 15 below average.
Warhawk 8/10 meta 84 4 below average.
Motorstorm 8/10 meta 83 3 below average.
Motorstorm: PC 7/10 meta 82 12 below average.
GT5: Prologue: 7/10 meta 80 10 below average.
Edge 360 scores:
Halo 3: ODST 9/10- meta 83 7 above average.
Halo 3 10/10 - meta 94 6 above average.
PGR4 9/10 meta 85 5 above average.
PGR3 9/10- meta 88 2 above average.
Fable II 9/10- meta 89 1 above average.
Left 4 Dead 9/10 meta 89 1 above average.
Left 4 Dead 2 9/10 meta 89 1 above average.
Forza 2 9/10 meta 90 Exactly average.
Ace Combat 6 8/10 meta 80 Exactly Average.
Forza 3- 9/10 meta 92 2 below average.
Gears Of War 2 9/10 meta 93 3 below average.
Crackdown 8/10 meta 83 3 below average.
Gears Of War- 8/10- meta 94 14 below average.
Banjo Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts: 7/10 meta 79 9 below average.
Mass Effect 2 9/10- meta 96 6 below average.
Mass Effect 7/10 - meta 91 21 below average.
Halo Wars- 7/10 meta 82 12 below average.
Dead Or Alive 4- 7/10 meta 85 15 below average.
The metacritic scores of course include the Edge scores in their average. I haven't included all exclusives, just the ones above 80 I could find. In general, they seem to score closer to the average with 360 games.
