Best casual controller, Wiimote or Natal?

[FreeTalkLive]

maximus22 said:

 

Now to the more important point. Saying that NSMBwii rapes LBP as a platformer is simply absurd to the point of comical.  While I agree that LBP can be glitchy at times, it is better in any category I can think of with the possible exceptions of crisp control.  And even that is such a small disadvantage that it is almost unnoticable.  Let's see, to list a few things that LBP does better: visuals, scope, soundtrack, replayability, variety, multiplayer, customability, physics, presentation.......   Don't get me wrong, I love NSMBwii with a nostalgic passion that I have for no other.  But to be honest, it is a last gen upgrade to Super Mario Bros. 3 and just can't compete with LBP on, ALMOST, any front. 

 

This topic is so much more interesting than motion controls for casuals :)

I own LBP and not NSMBWii (though I did borrow it for 5 weeks).  LBP is a fun game and there is a lot to do.  The platforming controls are not equal to SMB 1 on NES, though.  NSMBWii has great platforming controls.  I guess it depends on what you want out of a game.  I like both games but for different things.  LBP is innovative and interesting.  NSMBWii is a lot of fun with my friends.