Heavy Rain or Silent Hill : Shattered Memories? (spoilers probobly)

[MaxwellGT2000]

Pyramid Head said:
@maxwell

thats one area to be testd

ive beaten shsm 3 times

heavy rain only once, very curious how the replays will go i must admit

I really hope I'm not the only one that the controls didn't drive me mad! (I could go back and check to see if there's a way to change them) But I got really annoyed at holding down a button to walk while not holding it make it move the camera, then during the QTE fights the simi circles would sometimes not even register with me, same with the shaking the dualshock, and finally why is there a need to have an action on the controller for every little thing, pressing up to stand up? Quarter circle to pull something out of your pocket?  Why can't a lot of the little actions just be X to check/action. 

My other major flaw I found in the game, its a game where the whole idea is actions effect outcomes, you're given three options... except it doesn't tell you WHAT THE HELL THEY DO, press left, press right, or do quarter-circle... what do these do?  Even when it does list things to ask or say it's rather cryptic "press", "sympathy", "trick", "evidence", etc.  sometimes that simply isn't enough information about what you want to do in that situation, the bioware way of responses in games seems like it would have worked amazingly here.

/end of rant

Really not trying to crap on the game... really believe me people LOL, but I had issues and wanted to make sure I'm not the only one that had these problems.

As for replay I could see them both being about the same, but I hear there are plotholes which could be linked to having so many choices effecting things that (one reason you have a character going from one emotion swinging to the exact opposite emotion) and they couldn't craft as tight of a story as they could have if they trimmed a few things... so it might get tiresome to go for all the endings, and it might not pull you in because of those huge mood swings lol