Silent Hill: Shattered Memories by miles for me. Between the acting, the animations, and the controls for Heavy Rain I totally got turned off of that game... not exactly sure how long it is but I played to the point that I played the 4 characters and haven't went back...
Honestly if the game had a different premise and the controls didn't bug me to no end I could get into it, but I'm not a huge fan of the crime drama stories. But man that's the big draw to Silent Hill: SM, amazing suspenseful story that draws you in, makes you question things, and in the end when it gives you your profile and it pegs you to a T (as long as you were honest) it's crazy.
I really don't want to get into gameplay cause there's issues with both but Heavy Rain was a snooze fest until the fights while SH:SM was really tense when hell froze over but still gripping when not running for your life, only issue once you play through it you know when things are about to hit the fan and it takes away part of that grip for your second, third, fourth and fifth playthroughs 
MaxwellGT2000 - "Does the amount of times you beat it count towards how hardcore you are?"
Wii Friend Code - 5882 9717 7391 0918 (PM me if you add me), PSN - MaxwellGT2000, XBL - BlkKniteCecil, MaxwellGT2000
