Heavy Rain plot holes *spoilers*

[badgenome]

CrazyHorse said:

badgenome said:
The first one was pretty funny. I was racking my brain, trying to think which male characters Madison had even encountered aside from Ethan. When it turned out to be Shelby, her reaction seemed so stupid.

I guess that being as though she was a reporter working on the Oragami Killer case it would make sense that she knew a private detective (Shelby) was also working on the case.

Most of these really aren't plot holes and can be explained by using your own logical thinking. The only one that seems odd to me is Ethan finding the oragami figures after his blackouts and the only explanation I can think of is his guilt of loosing Jason has made him think he is the killer during these blackouts and so he is making the figures to satisfy that belief.

Alright, Mr. Smarty Pants, fill in this plot hole: why did no one tell Shelby that his brother John actually survived, made Commander, and is now starring in a super successful game franchise of his very own? That's not exactly the kind of information you withhold, and it could have saved a lot of lives.