MontanaHatchet said:
No, it's because I've seen you make comments like those before, and it's one of the reasons you have somewhat of a moderation history. Now while I don't approve of immigrants bullying perfectly innocent people who live in a nation, that doesn't mean you should deny immigrants completely. I'll give you an example. Let's say you have a city where there are 10,000 Muslims, 5,000 Jews, and 100,000 people of other religions (mostly Christian). Now, let's say that 1,000 of those Muslims go around and bully the Jewish residents. Would you really deny the other 9,000 Muslims the right to live there, and/or tell them to leave? Of course not. And that's what we're dealing with here. I'm just saying that there have been similar things that have happened in the United States, and that people who were afraid or persecuted moved to other areas (usually suburban). There are still plenty of other regions in Sweden that have very few immigrants, if that's what someone is looking for. And by the way, your Japan rebuttal made me laugh. You mean that the nation that's facing cripping economic and demographic problems, that's up to its eyeballs in debt, and is on the verge of collapse is the best example you could come up with? Besides, I'm not saying that the demographics are a problem now. Much of Europe still has a sizable working population that can support stable economies. But let's take Japan as an example again. By 2050, 1/3 people in Japan will be 65 years or older. How do you think they'll sustain their country with such a population? The answer is that they won't. Same with much of Europe, including Sweden. Whether you like it or not, your country and many others need immigration for various regions. How you deal with the consequences of failure in integration is entirely up to your politicians (who are doing SUCH A GOOD JOB). |
Of course yes. I like your example because it's a core thing of the immigration issue. Simply since we can't separate the wheat from the chaff (is that the right saying?), we actually, unfortunately, have to deny entry to the 9,000 innocent people if the 1,000 do too much damage.*
Japan has a stagnating economy, but they're doing just fine. I believe they have a bright future with their current policies. The need of immigration is a big myth used for strategic & political reasons, although immigration can be very beneficial under the right circumstances and conditions.
*EDIT: obviously I don't mean to kick the innocent people out if they're already here, but the principle should be used when you decide about the size of immigration.