Hmm...I still believe PM: TTYD is my all-time favorite Mario game

[fkusumot]

Soriku said:

fkusumot said:

Soriku said:

fkusumot said:

Soriku said:

fkusumot said:

Soriku said:
I said TTYD is the best Mario game. Best platformer is SMG.

What genre would you put TTYD in? RPG?

TTYD is RPG. Listen, TTYD is the BEST MARIO game ever, while SMG is the BEST PLATFORMER ever. Get it?

I get it. You have a category called "Mario Games" and TTYD is the best Mario game. There's a category called "Platformer" and SMG is the best platformer. TTYD is an RPG. What do you think is the best RPG?

Best RPG = KH or ToS. ToS and KH tie.

Right. So KH = TOS > TTYD > SMG. That's how the chips fall for you?

But SMG isn't the 4th (or rather 3rd since ToS = KH) best game for me. Unless you're only counting only games mentioned.

Yes, I'm only counting the games mentioned. If you would like to include more games please do.