Super Mario Galaxy is just too amazing

[MontanaHatchet]

Onimusha12 said:

MontanaHatchet said:

Onimusha12 said:

MontanaHatchet said:

Onimusha12 said:

Girl Gamer Elite said:

MontanaHatchet said:

Girl Gamer Elite said:
I got all 120 stars.

Game is Great. GAme like this will never be GOY because there are no guns or swords in it. A game needs to at least be raited T to be game of the year.

Oh, that's the spite talking.

Name a Single E raited game that has been the unanymous GOY in the last eight years.

Finally my list has value, here are the top GOYs for each year (game must earn at least two GOYs to be put on the list and are ordered by number of sites and reviewers who gave it GOY)

2006

1. Gears of War2. Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess3. Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion4. Okami

2005

1. Resident Evil 4

2004

1. Half-Life 22. Halo 23. World of Warcraft

2003

1. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic

2002

1. Metroid Prime2. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City

2001

1. Grand Theft Auto III

Sorry, I don't have any more unanymous GOYs before 2001. But as you can see, no E raited games at all.

 

Hmm, I wonder if it's possible that T-M rated games are just better quality.

Also, RCTjunkie, please go back to the cat avatar.

Onimusha: Wind Waker got GOTY from Gamespot, the most comprehensive game site in the world!!!

That's still only one GOY and I'm still waiting for you to provide me with a second.

Clearly with SMG we see T-M raited games are not always better quality, so that theory is bunk. You know as well as I do that the majority of reviewers live and die for the T-M franchises. Many have even said so themselves. This is no mystery.

I hope you realize that the Gamespot statement was a joke...

But then again,

Title	Plat	Company	Reviews	Avg. Vote	Avg Score
1. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time	N64	Nintendo	31	9.0	97.6%
2. Super Mario Galaxy	WII	Nintendo	50	8.8	97.5%
3. Metroid Prime	GC	Nintendo	92	8.8	96.3%
4. Soul Calibur	DC	Namco	27	8.8	96.3%
5. The Orange Box	X360	EA Games	47	9.1	96.2%
6. The Orange Box	PC	EA Games	29	9.6	96.1%
7. Tekken 3	PS	Namco	23	8.1	95.8%
8. Resident Evil 4	GC	Capcom	104	9.2	95.8%
9. Super Mario 64	N64	Nintendo	20	9.2	95.7%
10. Half-Life 2	PC	VU Games	93	8.9	95.5%

3 of the top 10 are E, 4 are M, 3 are T.

Those are not GOY though. This conversation was about GOY. It would seem your argument is getting a little thin. Face it Montana, you've lost this one. Hang it up.

"Clearly with SMG we see T-M raited games are not always better quality"

I will declare when I'm done.