Sometimes you can't worry about reviews, if you look down on that article, at other reviews, others gave MAG a 8/10 and 96% which are superb, The review is going to really base on the writers likes and dislikes as a gamer, so don't get to hung up on the reviews . Make up your own mind, remember its a first of its kind on a console, sales may start out slow but I really think in the long run it will get better, the game is really really fun ounce you put together a good team.Give it a chance.